Beyond Wrongdoing and Rightdoing

by Carla Royal on May 11, 2010

white horse Beyond Wrongdoing and Rightdoing

This is a view from the balcony of my new place.  Hot Shot is one of the horses I care for, a Missouri Foxtrotter, and he is a horse with an attitude.  Did he get his name because he acts like a hot shot, or does he act like a hot shot because he got the name?

A friend and I were talking the other day and she mentioned the biblical story of Adam naming the animals in the Garden of Eden.  I commented that the ability to name is both a blessing and a curse.  How much does labeling help us and how much does it limit us?

I have experienced the power of labels, both negatively and positively–mostly negatively.  I find it difficult to step out of a label once embraced, or to allow others to step out of the labels I have put on them.  I embraced some labels that I have since outgrown.  Shedding them has been something akin to shedding my skin.  At the same time, there are labels that I aspire to embrace. I want to be a kind, authentic person of integrity, for example.

So many words…

I think words often get in the way.  Maybe even the words “negatively” and “positively” get in the way.  Rumi says, “Out beyond ideas of Wrongdoing and Rightdoing, there is a field. I’ll meet you there. When the soul lies down in that grass, the world is too full to talk about. Ideas, language, and even the phrase each other doesn’t make any sense.” (translated by Coleman Banks, The Essential Rumi)

What would life be like in that field?  What would our relationships be like?  Who would I be out beyond wrongdoing and rightdoing?

Who would you be?

share save 171 16 Beyond Wrongdoing and Rightdoing

Related Posts:

  • Cara’s Mom

    I really look forward to your writings each day, and am glad your kind of thinking is out there. Thanks for being an inspiration to so many.

  • http://scintillatingspeck.wordpress.com Jen

    I love that Rumi poem so much. And I love that you aspire to being a kind, authentic person of integrity… that’s what I aspire to as well! To me, you are already there in that place of kindness, authenticity, and integrity.

    Back when I was much more of an academic (to use a label laden with both positive and negative associations for me!) I had explored in more detail the idea that language actually creates meaning. It blew my mind. I love language and yet I struggle with it constantly because it feels both incredibly powerful and also limiting. It illuminated for me, though, that I’m usually trying to use language as a tool to lessen the distance between me and others, and sometimes I just end up feeling the distance more.

    I love that your blog has both words and photos. The photos transcend the limitations of language in such a magical way. That shot of Hot Shot is enchanting.

  • Joan Bright

    I agree with Cara’s Mom, and with Jen. Hot Shot is a beautiful creature, and the picture is so peaceful and calm. Your blog is inspirational for me as well.
    I really like that Rumi poem. It reminds me that we are far more than ideas, and also that we are all together in Oneness. It reminds me that animals tend to think in pictures and colors and feelings and smells and sensations, and that I can take a break from word language if I listen for what they have to share with me/us/All.
    It is a very special thing to have the skills and the necessary physical vigor to care for horses. I know it takes a lot of work because I lived on a horse farm years ago for a short while. How awesome you can do this important work near your father at this time, and how beautiful a place you are in. Thanks for sharing your thoughts and the gorgeous picture.

  • Carla

    Thank you, friends.

    Cara’s Mom, you made me smile, and I felt immediate affection for you when you addressed yourself in that way. Thank you for your kind words.

    Jen, thank you for your continued support and affirmation. I see you the same way! I appreciate your thoughts.

    Joan, thank you for your support and kind, thoughtful words, as well. I do love the horses. Last night, I dreamed that I was flying beside a horse. I clearly wasn’t used to it and was a tad uncomfortable but the horse was fully enjoying it and was a comfort beside me.

Previous post:

Next post: